Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

Wilson v. Wexford Health Sources, Inc.

United States District Court, D. Maryland

May 14, 2014

TIWAN TONY WILSON, Plaintiff,
v.
WEXFORD HEALTH SOURCES, INC., Defendant.

MEMORANDUM

PAUL W. GRIMM, District Judge.

Plaintiff filed a complaint, alleging that he was receiving inadequate medical care in prison, ECF No. 1, and he filed a letter request for injunctive relief, specifically that Defendant send him to a hospital for further evaluation, ECF No. 7. I ordered Defendant to show cause why I should not grant Plaintiff the injunctive relief he requested. ECF No. 9. Pending is Defendant's response to my show cause order, filed together with its motion for summary judgment, ECF 10.[1] Plaintiff opposes the motion, ECF 15. Upon review of the pleadings filed, I find a hearing in this matter unnecessary. See Loc. R. 105.6 (D. Md. 2011). For the following reasons, I will grant Defendant's motion and deny Plaintiff's request for injunctive relief.

I. BACKGROUND

Plaintiff, an inmate confined at Eastern Correctional Institution ("ECI"), alleges that he has been coughing up blood since January 25, 2013. Initially, Plaintiff was told he was coughing up blood due to scar tissue from being shot and stabbed, but Plaintiff states he was never shot or stabbed in his chest. Rather, he was shot in his stomach in 2001 and stabbed in his shoulder in 2005. Plaintiff claims that, despite submitting sick call requests to prison medical staff, he has not been given a proper diagnosis. He states that the only treatment he has received consists of ineffective medications and treatment for asthma, allergies, and a cough. He also states that he has been provided medication to slow his heart rate, but believes that his heart palpitations are due to pain and shortness of breath. He alleges that doctors have been denying him a CT scan and that he has been placed on suicide watch because he is so worried about his health. According to Plaintiff, even though he has shown medical staff the blood he is coughing up, he still is denied testing at an outside hospital. Compl. 3, 5-7, ECF No. 1. In his opinion, the blood either is from cancer, id. at 5-7, or metal inside his chest, id. at 3.

In correspondence later filed with the Court, Plaintiff indicates that he was sent to a hospital for testing. Second Supp. 2, ECF No. 15. Additionally, he states that he reported to the infirmary for a sick call slip and the nurse listened to his breathing, but could not hear any sounds on one side of his chest. Plaintiff told medical staff at that time that he was in constant pain, that he continued to cough up blood, and that his lips were breaking out. In response to his statement regarding his lips, he claims Nurse Teri Davis remarked "in so many words" that the condition of his lips was due to Plaintiff performing fellatio. Plaintiff claims that Dr. Ashraf reported to the room and Plaintiff coughed up blood in the doctor's presence. Dr. Ashraf provided Plaintiff with pain medication, ordered more "cough pills, " and told Plaintiff his symptoms were due to the presence of metal in his chest. Plaintiff further claims that medical staff told him he was not a high priority and that he is treated as a troublemaker. Ltr. Req. for Injunctive Relief.

Due to the serious nature of Plaintiff's claims, I ordered Defendant to show cause why injunctive relief should not be granted, ECF No. 9. Defendant states that Plaintiff has a medical history which includes hypertension, diabetes, paranoid schizophrenia, depression, and chest and abdominal trauma from multiple gunshot and stab wounds.[2] Chem Aff. ¶¶ 5-6, Def.'s Mem. Ex. 2, ECF No. 10-4. Diagnostic imaging of Plaintiff's chest has revealed traumatic changes that are consistent with both injury and prior surgeries including surgical clips in the right lower lung, fibrotic changes in the mid-to-lower lung zones, decreased aeration of the right lung, and deformities of the ribs. Id. ¶¶ 6-8. Plaintiff's medical history also includes chronic chest pain unrelated to cardiac or respiratory/pulmonary problems. Id. ¶ 6. This history includes hemoptysis (coughing up blood), shortness of breath, upper respiratory disease, pneumonia, and empyema of the lung.[3]

In adults, 70 to 90 percent of cases of hemoptysis are caused by bronchitis, bronchiectasis, [4] tuberculosis, or necrotizing pneumonia.[5] The condition may indicate a mild or serious condition including a blood clot in the lung, chronic lung conditions like bronchitis or bronchiectasis, pulmonary aspiration or breathing blood into the lungs, cystic fibrosis, cancer of the respiratory tract, vasculitis or inflammation of the blood vessels of the lungs, injury to arteries of the lungs, bronchoscopy due to injury to the air passages, pneumonia or other infections of the lung, pulmonary edema, tuberculosis, or systemic lupus erthematosus.[6] Treatment for the condition includes treatment for the underlying cause, and if it is due to irritation of the throat, cough suppressant syrup can be used. Id. In Plaintiff's case, the initial suspicion confirmed by diagnostic imaging was that his condition was caused by the multiple traumas he experienced, which included five surgeries to address injuries caused by a gunshot wound and a stab wound. One of those surgeries included a splenectomy. EPHR Recs. 329, Def.'s Mem. Ex. 1, ECF No. 10-3.

Defendant has provided in excess of 300 pages of medical records in support of its motion for summary judgment. See id. Significant to the issue pending before the Court is a consultation report dated November 15, 2013, indicating that Plaintiff had been sent to Bon Secours Hospital for a pulmonary consultation and received a CT scan "a few weeks ago" which showed "lung mass suspicious of lung tumor for which pulmonary consult wants to do Bronchoscopy test." Id. at 336; see id. at 248 (indicating that Bon Secours pulmonary consultant requested: pulmonary function test done at Bon Secours; chest x-ray done at the prison; preadmission blood work; and bronchoscopy). A summary of a CT scan done on September 12, 2013

showed extensive pleural and parenchymal change in the posterior right lower lung associated with multiple rib deformities apparently related to the previous trauma from a stab wound and lung collapse [according] to the previous history. Extensive scarring in the posterior right lower lobe with a small pleural-based air cavity, which appears to have fistulous collection in the lower bronchus, previous gunshot wound to the left upper quadrant, splenectomy.

Id. at 330. Another summary of the same CT scan dated October 14, 2013, indicates a small metallic fragment was seen in the lung tissue as well as a deformity to the left diaphragm consistent with the history of previous trauma. Id. at 238. Medical providers acknowledged Plaintiff's weight loss, but noted that in the year prior Plaintiff had gained 30 pounds. Id. at 78.

It appears the request for the CT scan was generated on March 28, 2013, six months before the test was conducted. At that time, it was noted that Plaintiff was complaining of intermittent hemoptysis and there was a need to rule out bronchiectasis or pulmonary disease following his admittance to the prison infirmary. Id. at 112, 327. A chest x-ray taken two months prior to the request for a CT scan on January 28, 2013, revealed "post-traumatic changes." Id. at 323. On May 7, 2013, when Plaintiff was seen by Dr. Ashraf, it was noted that there were no signs or symptoms of hemoptysis or shortness of breath, prompting Ashraf to delay the CT scan. Id. at 128.

The bronchoscopy test requested by the Bon Secours pulmonary clinic was done on December 4, 2013. Those test results indicate that plaintiff has "a mild restrictive lung defect" with "mild decrease in diffusing capacity" which is interpreted as an "insignificant response to bronchodilator." Id. at 341. Plaintiff was given another bronchoscopy on February 7, 2014, which ruled out any presence of a tumor or other lesion. Operative Report 1-2, Def.'s Supp. Ex. 1, ECF No. 12-1. There was evidence of bronchiectasis with acute inflammation of the inner walls of Plaintiff's lungs; the surgeon noted that there was "splinter hemorrhages" when touched but that Plaintiff was not actively bleeding in his lungs. Id. at 1. The current plan of treatment for Plaintiff is stated in Dr. Jason Clem's affidavit as follows:

The treatment for bronchiectasis is aimed at controlling infections and bronchial secretions, relieving airway obstruction, and preventing complications. Based on these findings... plaintiff is presently receiving appropriate care for his pulmonary conditions which includes Symbicort a corticosteroid inhaler used to reduce inflammation of the lung, Guaifenesin an expectorant to thin and loosen mucus production and chest congestion and cough tabs.
Plaintiff will continue to be regularly followed for his pulmonary issues as a chronic care patient to monitor his condition and the effectiveness of his treatment plan in controlling his symptoms associated with ...

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.